Skip to content
MelbourneFixFix it, or find someone in Melbourne who can

Repair or replace?

Three numbers and a straight answer. The calculator weighs the repair quote against the price of a new one and how much life the item has left.

Fill in the three numbers above to see a recommendation.

How the calculator decides

It starts from the 50% rule that appliance technicians have used for decades: if a repair costs more than half the price of a new equivalent, replacement deserves serious thought. On its own that rule is too blunt, because it treats a two year old fridge and a twelve year old fridge the same way.

So the calculator tightens the threshold as the item ages. A nearly new item is worth a bigger repair, because you get years of use from the money. An item near the end of its typical life justifies only a small one, because the next failure is probably not far behind.

The lifespans are broad rules of thumb. A well-maintained appliance from a good brand can outlast them comfortably, and a cheap one may not reach them.

What the numbers cannot tell you

  • Your consumer rights. If the item failed early, the seller may have to repair or replace it at no cost, whatever the warranty says. Read your consumer rights first.
  • Running costs. A new heat pump dryer, fridge or split system can use far less electricity than a fifteen year old one. For appliances that run every day, that saving is real money.
  • Installation. Built-in ovens, dishwashers and ducted systems cost extra to swap, and a new model may not fit the old opening. Add that to the replacement price.
  • The fault itself. A one-off failure such as a pump or an element is different from a pattern of breakdowns. Ask the repairer what condition the rest of the machine is in.
  • Waste. Manufacturing a new appliance has an environmental cost that does not appear on the receipt. If the sums are close, repair is the lower-impact choice.

If you decide to replace

Anything with a plug, cord or battery is banned from landfill in Victoria. Our e-waste guide lists drop-off points and the retailers that take the old appliance away on delivery. If the item still works, or nearly works, consider donating it or taking it to a repair cafe.

If you decide to repair

Check a typical price in the repair cost guide, then compare a couple of businesses in the repairer directory.